Customer Review(s)
Customer Rating: 
Summary: Moving
Comment: When C.S.Lewis, author of such books as "The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe" was only a small boy of 9, his mother died and he learned that his only way through the pain and loneliness was to encase himself in an impenetrable shell, so that pain could not touch him. He leads an ordered, safe life as an Oxford Don, singing in the cathedral choir and lecturing to audiences of adoring women readers. When he meets American writer, Joy Gresham, her brash, New York, Jewish forthrightness almost batters him but luckily he summons enough courage to begin a friendship. He agrees to marry her so as to allow her and her son to remain in England and gradually she softens his defences and becomes part of his life as a platonic friend. When they discover that Joy is dying from incurable cancer, Lewis realises the depth of his love for her which allows them to enjoy a brief few months together before she dies. Anthony Hopkins is brilliantly cast as Lewis and is such a fine actor that the viewer is able to see, in his eyes, everything that he is saying inwardly, while Debra Winger is equally as good as the loud American who is the foil for his timidity.
Customer Rating: 
Summary: Beautiful and Infuriating
Comment: This movie is beautiful and has lovely acting and gorgeous sets and even terrific writing.
The directing, as usual with Attenborough, is first-rate.
But Lewis is an infuriating person.
That's partly the movie's subject: Lewis is SO repressed, SO insulated, SO narcissistic, that it takes a very aggressive woman and a tragedy to (partly) penetrate his shell.
He wrote a book called "Surprised by Joy." This is a reference to Wordsworth; but it seems perfectly apt--and horrifying.
You get the sense from this movie that Lewis was so cut off from the emotions that anything--even pain--was better than the numbness in which he spent most of his life.
It's sad, and it's pointless.
Oddly--or perhaps not oddly at all--Lewis erects Pain into his First Principle of Theology: for Lewis, God does not want us to be happy, He wants us to Suffer, because by Suffering we learn to love.
It is pitiful that Lewis had to suffer to learn love.
Hard to know why Joy would love him.
You don't know whether to laugh or scream at him.
Great movie about a pitiable person.
Customer Rating: Summary: Not a Documentary but a Commentary
Comment: This movie fails to be the documentary based on "true story" but a commentary by the director and actors which fails to provide the essential Lewis story.
What is left out primarily is his faith life, which was vital to him, and he wrote about till the end. It is analogous to making film about Tiger Woods with golf as not being featured as central theme. It was not shaken nor destroyed as this movie makes out. The BBC film which proceeded this, thus is far more accurate than this. Hopkins' interpreation of Lewis as isolated in tower and afraid to take on debate is also inaccurate. His relationship with Joy is also inaccurate in many ways.
Three stars for with all this Hollywood inaccuracy, many are motivated to seek out real Lewis is his writings and thus discover this fine, intelligent Christian.
