Customer Review(s)
Customer Rating: 



Summary: Quite possibly the worst movie I've ever seen
Comment: So, so bad. Sort of a "Oliver Twist" - boy deprived of his rightful destiny, in this case musical genius; and his misadventures while "following the music". The film had so many plot holes that made it absolutely impossible to buy into the story. I never believed from the get go that the two musicians fell in love, that they could never have found each other earlier, that a baby could be born and given to an orphanage without the mother's consent or even knowing what really happended, etc. etc.
The dialouge was insipid and contrived; the dialouge during the scene where the two musicians have their once in life time one night stand;actually made me cringe it was so melodramatic and stupid.
This movie is quite possibly the worst movie I've ever seen because of it's pretentiousness while it actually insults the intelligence of its audience.
Customer Rating: 



Summary: Completely Unbelievable!
Comment: We rented this movie after my sister said it was her favorite movie of '08. I found it completely unrealistic. I wonder if anyone really musical was involved in creating the storyline of this movie.
One major flaw was Lyla's special invitation to be a featured performer after 11 years of not really playing the cello. Is there a Julliard graduate out there who can confirm that after such a long lapse in practicing, there is any way that Lyla can brush up in (what appeared to be) a week, and give a stunning performance to a discerning audience?
Another impossibility is Evan/August's theory progress in one day. It doesn't matter how amazing your genes are, you will not be writing 16th notes and more in your first day of composing if you've only been introduced to basic quarter notes in a beginner piano book. How absurd! And speaking of genes, although his parents were gifted musicians, Evan had ZERO exposure to music except in-utero and out in nature(??) until he was 11. A musical prodigy may have musical genes, but is also heavily exposed to music. Mozart began playing the harpsichord at age 3 and didn't begin composing until about 6. He did not hop on the piano the first day and compose.
Just two examples of many absurdities. Perhaps the greatest is the idea of two people pining after each other for 11 years after a one-night-stand. Is this really "great for the whole family?" I found myself relating to Lyla's dad (being protective after the party-not forging signatures and lying), who was made out to be a villain in the movie.
I do think the boy did a great job acting.